I am as likely as anyone to criticize Carl Pavano, but that doesn't mean I will root against him tonight. When you really sit down and think about it, Pavano is probably the worst signing in team history and the really sad thing is it should have been a good story. Remember the press conference and Carl and his family, all Yankees' fans smiling for the cameras? Remember that shutout he pitched in Seattle when the 2005 Yankees were getting off the mat and recovering from an 11-19 start with a ten-game winning streak? Carl Pavano had the fans on his side and then he got hurt and it all went downhill from there.
I like Mike Mussina and when he called out Pavano I noticed. I think Pavano decided at some point in his many injury rehabs that he had had enough and he didn't want to play baseball anymore. The honorable thing to do would have been to retire, but you don't earn $10 million a year in retirement. So, Pavano half-assed his rehab, didn't tell the team about his car crash and all the other things we have read about the past three years. Contrast that with the way Hideki Matsui basically willed his knee to get better this season. Mussina wasn't the only one who criticized Pavano for a lack of heart, some players posted insulting stories about him in his locker. So, it is fair to say that some of those players will probably not welcome him back tonight.
Over the last couple of days I have seen some pretty shocking articles about Pavano. Some suggested that the Yankees shouldn't start him out of spite. Some, like this one, suggest that Pavano will kill any momentum the team has by setting foot in the locker room. Both are silly points to try and make.
The Yankees cannot play the spite game with Pavano. When they decline his option at the end of the season both sides will move on from this unhappy marriage, but until then they owe it to everyone to see if they can wring out some value from him. To deliberately keep him out of the majors as some have suggested is silly. If it helps Pavano get a deal from another club next season, so be it. The Yankees can't care about that right now and there fans shouldn't worry about it. If Pavano wins all his starts and is brilliant on the mound that is great for the Yankees. If some club sees that and gives him a big deal as a result, that is there problem And, while there are some Yankees who can't stand Pavano, all of them are professionals and they want to win.
As for the fans, we are free to boo if we want. If Pavano ever takes the mound at the Stadium I would imagine his reception would be very, very cold. He deserves all the boos he gets and while I would never tell someone they can't boo, ask yourself before you do so, does this help my team win? Instead of booing, I would recommend just sitting silent, turn your back even, it would be much more powerful. But hopefully, Pavano gives us something to cheer about because like it or not, we need pitching right now.